MODI IS WRONG, BUT HINDUSTAN’S HINDU IS NOT | BY DR. ZAKIR NAIK IN PAKISTAN
In one of his thought-provoking speeches in Pakistan, Dr. Zakir Naik emphasized a crucial distinction that is often overlooked in political and social discourse: the difference between a political leader’s actions and the beliefs of an entire community. He boldly declared, “Modi is wrong, but Hindustan’s Hindu is not.” This statement highlights the importance of separating political motives from the genuine nature of everyday citizens in India, particularly the Hindus.
Understanding the Context
Dr. Zakir Naik, a renowned Islamic scholar and speaker, has often been critical of the political actions taken by Narendra Modi, especially during his tenure as the Chief Minister of Gujarat and later as the Prime Minister of India. Modi has faced international scrutiny for his alleged involvement in promoting an anti-Muslim agenda, most notably during the Gujarat riots in 2002, which resulted in the deaths of many Muslims.
Despite these controversies, Dr. Naik has consistently reminded his audiences that not every Hindu supports the divisive and violent rhetoric that some political figures, like Modi, may propagate. In fact, many Hindus in India live peacefully alongside Muslims and respect the principles of co-existence, tolerance, and harmony that are deeply rooted in Indian culture.
Why Modi is Wrong?
Dr. Zakir Naik pointed out that Modi’s political strategies often play on religious sentiments, using them to gain votes and fuel communal tensions. The rise of right-wing nationalism under his government has led to increased polarization between Hindus and Muslims in India. Whether it is the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), the crackdown on dissent, or the vilification of Indian Muslims, Modi’s policies have created an environment of fear and division.
In Naik’s view, these actions not only undermine the secular fabric of India but also damage the international image of the country, which has long been admired for its diversity and peaceful co-existence of various religious groups.
Hindustan’s Hindus Are Not Wrong
In stark contrast to Modi’s approach, Dr. Naik stressed that the Hindu population of India, by and large, does not endorse such hate-driven politics. He praised the many Hindus who have stood up for the rights of their Muslim neighbors, speaking out against discrimination and violence. These individuals embody the true spirit of India, a nation founded on the principles of inclusivity and respect for all faiths.
Dr. Naik also highlighted the shared history between Hindus and Muslims in India, pointing out that they have lived together for centuries, building a rich and diverse culture that is admired worldwide. From the Mughal era to the modern day, India has thrived because of its ability to embrace and celebrate its differences.
A Call for Unity
Dr. Zakir Naik’s message is clear: the actions of political leaders should not define entire communities. While Modi’s government may push an agenda that divides, the everyday Hindu in India is not the enemy of Muslims. Instead, they are often allies in the struggle for justice, peace, and equality.
By recognizing this distinction, Muslims and Hindus alike can resist the divisive tactics used by those in power and work towards a future where all communities in India, regardless of religion, can live together in harmony.
Conclusion
Dr. Zakir Naik’s speech in Pakistan serves as a reminder that we must look beyond the actions of a few individuals in power and see the larger picture. Modi may be wrong in his approach, but Hindustan’s Hindus should not be painted with the same brush. It is essential to foster understanding and unity between communities, rather than allowing the politics of hatred to dictate our relationships. Only then can India live up to its true potential as a diverse and harmonious nation.
